This creates a simple calculation to prioritise design changes.
“In that vision we are trying to have a renewed and purposeful store network, with a new service model, that delivers more value to consumers and more business performance.”
Implementing ‘design Darwinism’
For Aldo, one solution has been online appointments, allowing customers to set up one-to-ones with associates online, before visiting a store. This in turn enables store visits (while restrictions are in place) to become easier and more seamless.
Ultimately, Aldo has strived to ‘make life easier’ and to enable associates to service customers on whatever platforms they prefer. The retailer is currently working on a number of new features to enable this, including a ‘save for later’ option which involves store associates sending customers links that they might be browsing in store but are unsure about buying. A stronger chat service is also in the works, as well as assisted selling.
“This was one of the key learnings that we have generated through these type of pilots, in how we should explore, iterate, and test and learn to improve the service model in store,” says Baret.
One example of this credo in practice is Aldo’s testing of interactive screens in store to allow customers to discover products. Despite what consumers said to the brand when testing in the labs – e.g. “we like this tool, it is super useful” etc – the performance was not good in store.
Reducing cognitive load and doubt
“Beyond the new procedures and all the restrictions, the main thing we have seen from our retail service model is – more than ever – we need to provide added services and convenience and to adopt new ways to interact with consumers.”
Baret describes experience design as all about “designing services to enhance the shopping experience.”
So, how can a brand like Aldo find the right opportunities, without getting bogged down in testing too many ideas at once? Baret advocates what he calls “design Darwinism”.
“The very moment where I am enticing you to check this size tool, this is not only giving you guidance, but it is questioning you – ‘is it the right size?’ or ‘is it not the right size?’” explains Beret. “When looking at the reviews, they were also leading consumers to question the reality of those reviews and what is the truth. Strangely, all of these tools that are known to be essential in ecommerce ended up not performing that well.”
Achieving Omnichannel Excellence
Finally, Aldo’s ‘express pickup’ increases speed of interaction in store. “Don’t think that buying on the web is so fast, simple, and instant, and that coming in store will be such a painful experience,” says Baret. “No, we can find ways to make all of this efficient and super-fast, while adding the value of interacting with a human being.”
“What we mean by that is that we don’t believe the ‘wake-up call’ about the interaction between store and web was negative. The opposite – we have seen that this is an opportunity to be even smarter in the way we leverage the stores to be part of the full experience, and to be part of the service model.”
Paying attention to what consumers are doing (not saying)
This omnichannel focus was thrown off course earlier in the year, of course, as – like many other retailers – Aldo stores were forced to close due to Covid-19.
“So, each time you come in store, if you need a product we will be able to quickly check if it is available, and if so, we can quickly a request a runner in the back store to bring you the product. If the product is not there, we can showcase some recommendations.”
Baret cites an example of one particular A/B test, which involved comparing a standard ecommerce page (containing features including reviews and a sizing tools) with a ‘naked product page’.
“We can’t rely on our intuition about what is a good or wrong design, we used to say to our designers ‘don’t fall in love with your design’ because we are going to expose the design in the context of reality, and to tweak it based on what people actually do.”
He explains how it is crucial to consider biases, such as ‘lip service’, meaning that people don’t always do what they say. “They might tell you that they love a feature and that they would interact with it, but you need to test it to understand what is going on in reality.”
Aldo uses the ‘RICE priority score’ – reach x impact x confidence / effort – where reach is how many people you are possibly impacting; impact is about how much it is moving conversion; confidence is to what extent you know it is going to work; and effort is the technical and operational challenge and how complex it is going to be.
“How could we find better synergies between the store and ecommerce?” he asks. “What is the best way to leverage the associate in-store even when it is closed, for better shipping, better delivery, connection at a distance?”
In the end, after iteration, the team found that comparing the initial fixed touch screen with a new mobile device, the latter was found to be far more consistent in performance and went on to grow in usage over time.
Explore, iterate, test and learn
“The idea is really to find ways to establish – through tools and process – what are the ideas, services, or future, that are going to survive through ‘selection’ and survive to fit with specific performance criteria. We are trying to compare and score everything we do and we use a very simple process for that.”
From the product page stock quantities to shipping from stores (which is an important part of Aldo’s business model), suddenly all of these tools were not relevant. As stores have reopened, Baret explains how this has led Aldo to question ‘what is the connection between online and offline?’
Baret comments,“We kept on trying and thought ‘maybe what we need to do is have the tool introduced by the associate in store, and to get the consumer to interact with the tool for some very specific benefits.”
Reducing friction to focus on interactions that matter
“What we mean by that is evolving the way you connect with consumers through ecommerce – whether it’s redesign, new features you want to add, better ways to connect ecom and stores,” he explains. “It’s also about evolving the store experience and enhancing the way you interact with your consumers in-store.”
On the back of the test, Aldo rolled out mobile devices in all stores across North America. “This totally changed the way we do business, in our ability to be faster with consumers but also to capture data about the level of consumer interest in products – even if they don’t purchase,” says Baret.
Aldo uses a variety of tools, ranging from AB and multivariate testing to consumer feedback, in order to uncover insights about the retail experience and design.
“It doesn’t mean that we don’t need these tools, but the way they were implemented was wrong, and that we need to find a way to simplify and elevate some of these cognitive loads to make sure that we don’t infuse some doubt during your experience.”
“Our website that we built to be fully meshed with our stores was not crippled, but very impacted. We suddenly had the obligation to adapt to store closures, and to disable a lot of services,” says Baret.
“The more we were to add some of these new tools, the more we were adding cognitive load and friction and the more, in fact, we were adding doubt.”
“I have a new signal that is informing performance measurement that I can use for new experiments, that are also informing future strategies for inventory and location.”
Making life easier for consumers amid Covid
In terms of its ecommerce site, Aldo has focused on reducing friction “as well as smartly connecting with stores, making sure that you can discover online what is available in store, deliveries to store, and having that natural connection.”
Another feature Aldo has implemented since Covid is product reservation, allowing customers to check availability and book a visit. “It’s super seamless, it’s super-fast, it means that when you come into the store we already have information about the consumer and where they are coming from.” says Baret.
Baret admits that “..the better insights we do have are coming from the actual reality of implementation.” In other words, don’t listen to users, but pay attention to what they do.
“The main idea of an ecommerce page is to reduce any doubts. So, we were expecting the page [with all the aforementioned features] to be the best performer. Surprisingly, we found the [naked page] to be the best performing one.”
The idea behind the tool is that it reduces the frustration of waiting.
Other biases can stem from the geography of the store, the newness effect (meaning expected levels of excitement to begin with before a drop off), form factors, timing, or immediacy vs. delay (increase in sales but detrimental to equity).